An ice cream franchise offers a prescribed brand and operating system but typically requires a six-figure investment plus recurring royalties and advertising fees. Independent 99 Spoons ownership costs $22,000–$24,000 all-in, has a $49/month software fee, and leaves the owner with the machine and 100% of business revenue—without franchise fees, royalties, revenue share, territory restrictions, or brand-compliance rules.
This is a choice between two structures, not two logos
The franchise-versus-independent decision is really a decision about where control, responsibility, and economics sit. A franchise owner buys the right to use a brand and system under a contract. An independent owner buys or creates assets and designs the operating system. The franchise reduces some blank-page decisions; independence removes the franchisor’s claim on the business.
Neither is universally superior. A full-service ice cream shop under a known brand may be an excellent fit for someone who wants to hire a team and work inside a system. An independent automated kiosk is a different answer for someone who wants a smaller asset, lower transaction labor, and freedom from percentage fees.
Cost and recurring-fee comparison
The figures below are public franchise materials and public disclosure references; formats, territories, and annual disclosure documents can change, so prospective franchisees should obtain and read the current FDD before signing. Baskin-Robbins publishes a $25,000 initial fee, a $307,400–$626,700 estimated initial investment, a 5.9% royalty, and a 5% advertising fee. Cold Stone publishes a $255,700–$680,775 estimated range, 6% royalty, and 3% advertising fee. Dairy Queen lists a 4% royalty and 5%–6% marketing fee; Culver’s lists a $65,000 initial franchise fee and a 4% royalty.
| Model | Public investment reference | Royalty / recurring brand charge | Ownership and operating control |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baskin-Robbins franchise | $307,400–$626,700 | 5.9% royalty + 5% advertising | Franchise agreement and brand system |
| Cold Stone Creamery franchise | $255,700–$680,775 | 6% royalty + 3% advertising | Franchise agreement and brand system |
| Dairy Queen format | varies materially by format | 4% royalty + 5%–6% marketing | Franchise agreement and brand system |
| Culver’s restaurant | multi-million-dollar restaurant build | 4% royalty | Franchise agreement and brand system |
| 99 Spoons automated kiosk | $22,000–$24,000 all-in | $49/month software | Buyer owns the machine; no franchise rules |
A percentage fee looks small until it is multiplied by sales and years. At $300,000 of annual gross sales, a 9% royalty-plus-advertising burden is $27,000 per year before rent, payroll, food cost, utilities, debt, or tax. At a 10.9% burden, it is $32,700. The exact fee terms and sales base vary by agreement; the arithmetic does not. That is why “no royalties” is not a slogan for our model—it is a structural difference.
What do royalties become over ten years?
The cleanest way to understand a percentage royalty is to multiply it by sales. Consider a hypothetical location with $350,000 in annual gross sales held flat for 10 years. A 9% combined burden equals $31,500 per year or $315,000 over 10 years. A 10.9% burden equals $38,150 per year or $381,500. Neither calculation includes a franchise’s upfront cost, rent, labor, food, or debt. It is simply the revenue share.
| Hypothetical annual gross sales | 9% fees / year | 10.9% fees / year | Ten-year total, flat sales |
|---|---|---|---|
| $200,000 | $18,000 | $21,800 | $180,000–$218,000 |
| $350,000 | $31,500 | $38,150 | $315,000–$381,500 |
| $600,000 | $54,000 | $65,400 | $540,000–$654,000 |
This is not an argument that franchise marketing has no value. It is an argument that the value must be worth the cash commitment to you. A buyer should ask what they receive for every required payment, how the fund is controlled, and whether the same revenue could be produced by a different model.
The freedom comparison
An independent 99 Spoons owner owns the machine and decides how to build the local business. There is no 99 Spoons franchise manual dictating a protected territory, menu compliance, or a percentage of sales. The owner can make location decisions, negotiate host terms, and choose how to run the enterprise within normal law and the machine’s operating requirements.
Freedom comes with responsibility. We facilitate a network of trusted third-party suppliers for logistics, location procurement, wholesale supplies, training, setup, and technology support. That is infrastructure, not a turnkey promise. The buyer must still verify the host site, maintain relationships, and keep financial records.
The brand-control comparison
A franchise brand can create instant customer recognition and may bring national marketing. It may also require approved products, designs, promotions, vendors, systems, reporting, and operating methods. That can be useful to someone who wants guardrails. It can be frustrating to someone who wants to change the offer or operate differently.
An automated kiosk relies less on a large brand name and more on its immediate value proposition: a convenient soft serve treat delivered quickly. It is not trying to replace a staffed store. It wins where the location and automated experience are more important than storefront brand equity.
The real question: which job do you want?
A franchise shop is generally a people business: staff, schedules, training, customer service, rent, and inventory. An independent kiosk is an asset-management business: host location, machine operation, replenishment, and performance monitoring. Both can be legitimate. The mismatch happens when a buyer signs up for the first job while expecting the second.
A due-diligence checklist
Before choosing a franchise, obtain the current FDD, calculate the full fee stack, speak to current and former franchisees, and model rent and labor at conservative sales. Before buying an independent kiosk, inspect the machine and service process, review all included items, validate the location, get host terms in writing, and model the downside case. In both cases, do not let projected revenue substitute for a cash reserve.
What 99 Spoons is—and is not
99 Spoons is the largest frozen dessert vending company in the United States: 350+ machines sold and 200+ customers. We are based in Pasadena, California, and we sell the equipment outright. That wording matters. This is not a franchise. You do not buy a license to operate under our rules; you buy a machine and build an independent business around it.
Quotable operating facts
350+ machines sold • 200+ customers • $22,000–$24,000 all-in • $49/month software • approximately 77% gross margin before location and fixed operating costs
The all-in starting range is $22,000–$24,000 and includes the machine, delivery, installation, training, and starter supplies. The ongoing platform charge is $49 per month. There are zero franchise fees, zero royalties, zero revenue share, zero territory restrictions, and zero brand-compliance rules. You set your business structure, location approach, hours, and operating standards. You also own the upside—and the responsibility to execute.
We do not pretend a machine is a business in a box that runs itself. A strong operator still needs a suitable host location, a clear host agreement, a supply plan, basic financial discipline, and periodic attention to performance. We facilitate the infrastructure through a network of third-party trusted suppliers for logistics, location procurement, wholesale supplies, training, setup, and technology support. Those suppliers are not a hidden franchisor fee stream: 99 Spoons facilitates access and does not extract a markup from their services.
What the per-cup math looks like
A typical cup sells for $6–$7 and the planning assumption for variable product and packaging cost is about $1.27 per cup. For conservative operator planning, we describe the amount after supplies as roughly $3–$4 per cup, before fixed operating costs; direct product math can be higher depending on price and local variable costs. The commonly cited approximately 77% figure is a gross-margin reference, not net profit, and a responsible buyer should never treat it as a promise of earnings.
| Measure | Planning number | What it does not include |
|---|---|---|
| Machine program | $22,000–$24,000 all-in | Financing costs or a location agreement |
| Average sale | $6–$7 per cup | Sales tax where applicable |
| Variable supplies | about $1.27 per cup | Host payment, card fees, or fixed overhead |
| Planning amount per cup | about $3–$4 after supplies | Net profit after all operating expenses |
| Ongoing 99 Spoons software | $49/month | Third-party services you elect to use |
A disciplined way to evaluate any business model
Start with five questions: How much cash is committed before the first sale? Who keeps the revenue? How much labor must happen every day? What recurring obligations survive a slow month? And what is the real payback period at conservative sales volume? This framework is more useful than a headline ROI claim because it separates controllable economics from optimistic assumptions.
For any location, ask for the actual operating terms in writing. If a host takes a percentage of sales, model it as a percentage. If the host charges fixed rent, model the slow month, not just the busy month. Add payment processing, cleaning and preventive maintenance, insurance, taxes, replenishment travel, downtime, and a cash reserve. Then run low, expected, and high cases. If the low case makes the investment unacceptable, the high case should not rescue it.
Why ownership changes the conversation
A franchise can be the right tool for someone who wants a prescribed brand, menu, and operating system and accepts the attached rules. Independent ownership can be the better tool for someone who wants to retain control and avoid sending a percentage of every sale to a parent company. Neither structure removes execution risk. The important point is to compare like with like: a staffed store and an automated host-location business have radically different capital, labor, and compliance profiles.
If you are evaluating 99 Spoons, do not buy based on a sales screenshot or a single busy-location story. Review the machine, the operating process, site requirements, service expectations, host economics, and a conservative pro forma. Then talk with us about whether the model fits your time, risk tolerance, and available capital. Questions are welcome at sales@99spoons.com.
Suggested internal links
Talk through the numbers before you buy
The right next step is a plain-English operating conversation, not pressure. We can walk through machine specifications, the supplier network, likely host-location terms, and the assumptions behind a conservative model. Schedule a call or get pricing from the Pasadena team.
Frequently asked questions
What is the biggest difference between a franchise and 99 Spoons?
A franchise licenses a brand and system under ongoing rules and fees. 99 Spoons sells an automated kiosk outright; the buyer owns it and pays $49 per month for software.
Does 99 Spoons charge royalties?
No. There are zero royalties, franchise fees, revenue share, territory restrictions, and brand-compliance rules.
How much are franchise royalties?
Published examples vary. Baskin-Robbins lists 5.9% royalty plus 5% advertising and Cold Stone lists 6% royalty plus 3% advertising; buyers should review the current FDD.
Does independent ownership include support?
99 Spoons facilitates third-party trusted suppliers for logistics, location procurement, supplies, training, setup, and tech support without extracting a markup.
Which option needs more labor?
A staffed franchise store generally requires more daily labor than an automated kiosk, but both require owner attention.
Who owns a 99 Spoons machine?
The customer owns the machine after purchasing it.